… A Couple of Steps Closer to How…
Welcome back. I’m writing this under the assumption that you’ve read Part One. While I hadn’t intended to create a multi-part post, I realized that Cam, in his sharing, had done so for me. I’d encourage you to read Cam’s essay. It’s an eloquent sharing of what our search is all about. In his analysis of the ways in which he is applying Dr. Ryan’s 5 Questions Ryan’s 5 Questions to his thinking and explorations, Cam led into another question which I’m paraphrasing here…
What would learning look like if we acted on both our knowledge and our beliefs about it?
While not exactly Mueller-like in the level of detail he offers about how schools and learning might look, Cam shares some very concrete examples of things that he has done to close the gap between what we know and what we are currently doing in most schools.
Cam begins his reflection with some observations about the dissonance between how both kids and adults seem to learn best and what happens in schools as they are traditionally organized and configured.
And so the “guitar story”
…my 6-year-old starts guitar lessons today. He is very excited: he told me so at 5:00 am. When my partner and I began looking for teachers we had lots of criteria. My number one criteria is that there be no “curriculum” – how many amazing musicians never got beyond formal, conservatory based lessons and fail to see themselves as musicians later in life. I would argue far more than see themselves as musicians. This kind of approach to learning music does little to foster lifelong learning; it’s an exercise in resiliency: if you last you get to the good stuff; if not, you stop playing. My only measure of success for my son learning guitar will be if he still loves it on the other end. Like Springsteen writes about his first guitar experience in Born to Run, if my son quits because it’s hard, and loves it all the same, that’s success for now. One day, who knows?
A key difference that came to mind this morning is relevant here: Contrast this to my experience of dropping him off at the bus today: you’d be hard pressed to find a more somber looking group of kids at 8 o’clock in the morning than those being transported to school. It was a bright, sunny, relatively warm Wednesday morning and every kid in every window looked…well, not excited to be there, or, I extrapolate, not excited about where they’re headed.
“I wonder why…we’d start with schools.”
I wonder why learning organizations of any kind would turn to schools for examples of best practice before looking to the myriad examples of lifelong learning in the community. There is a wealth of evidence of learning in what education terms extracurricular, and I’m inclined to think that deeper, more life altering individual development happens here.
If one was to consult the vast opportunities for non-credentialed, adult learning that people turn to cultivate passions outside of their working day one begins to see a disconnect in learning practice from what one sees in schools. In fact, if one looks to all the learning that children and youth do outside of school one would find similar examples.
Why, as a parent, would I scrutinize the quality of learning for my son’s guitar lessons, while blindly sending him off on the sad-bus for school?
…Maybe the better way, the more organic way, for me anyway, is to say it this way: “Would I want my children to learn this way…?” If the answer is no, then I hope there is a very quick, “Wait, what?”,followed by an “I wonder why…?” to follow. Why are we profering learning in our schools, in our Alt. program, that we would not support for our own children? Especially when we see a more effective alternative in their extracurriculars.
“Couldn’t we at least…” work towards a learning organization. A place that acknowledges the challenges our students arrive with. Couldn’t we at least strive to be something better? We are hardly scraping the surface of what we can do. Couldn’t we at least try? “Learn like no one is watching.” Couldn’t we strive to learn this way….Couldn’t we at least stop being afraid that our existence is contingent on being rigid. Our existence is contingent on being awesome for students asking for all kinds of different awesome questions. We can strive for that, can’t we? [Ron Edmunds said it this way: “…we can, wherever and whenever we choose, successfully teach all of the children whose schooling is of interest to us. We already know more than we need to do that. Whether or not we do it must finally depend on how we feel about the fact we haven’t so far.”
We’ve had lots of conversations about why, when people know in their hearts that school could be something better, do we continue to “do school” as we’ve known and experienced it? When we talk about why there is such a gap between what we know and what we do, we inevitably come to face to face with our fears. We are inundated with “what if” questions… almost all of them are about the consequences of failure. The list of these fears is as long as the number of people on our staff… each has their own version, their own fear(s).
These fears drive us to ask “how” questions: How will I manage giving kids choices? How will I grade them? What if they choose to do something that we don’t usually cover? What if they screw up the state test? Etc., etc. etc.
Here’s how Cam took steps. He describes this in his response to Ryan’s “How Can I Help?” question. He offers two experiences as something he shared with colleagues to help them see what learning might look like.
But did I ever tell you about the time (last week!) a student presented to a room full of people she invited – her family, her friends, her teachers? The presentation was inspired by Change School; when John Clements dropped into a Coaching Session and told us about Back to the Future. I paired this concept with an idea Patrick shared with me months ago, and suggested this to a student–a brilliant young woman who writes like no one’s business–I said: “Imagine you 5 years from now. The aspirational you. Present about her. Then have her come back to you now and show you how to get there.” Something like that anyway. Her presentation was the most beautiful piece of performance art I’ve witnessed as a teacher. Stunning. Brilliant. Poignant. That’s how I help. I try alongside my students, as learners together. And bear witness to the trying. And make the learning and trying visible. [italics mine]
Cam’s second experience is a bit more “beyond the walls” and responds to the question, “Couldn’t we at least…?”
This is Jacob. One day in February he and 24 students from the Alternate Program joined me at the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers (IBEW) – a partnership a year in the making – for a Pre-Apprenticeship training opportunity. The experience was open to anyone. Experience was unnecessary. Jacob had no experience. He was frustrated at the outset: the instruction did not make sense to him (it was the minimum viable instruction), and he was sitting at a plywood circuit, with a circuit diagram and did not know where to start. I checked-in: he voiced his frustration. I suggested he ask a question and gave him some space. Jacob worked for 4.5 hours; struggling, seeing others around him complete the circuit and move on, seeing success, not necessarily in himself. At the end of the day, this hardened learner who revealed nothing of his emotional rollercoaster all day, stepped up to the circuit testing lab. Everyone in the room was packing up, cleaning up, waiting at the door for taxis. Jacob was hauling his completed circuit to the testing lab. The instructor, George, noticed him and met him at the lab. He checked the circuit, explained what he was looking for. Jacob revealed nothing of what was going on in his head. George moved out of the way to give Jacob space to flip the switch. What does learning look like? This is what learning looks like. That smirk you see, magnify it by 100 times; when that light literally and metaphorically turned on. Jacob could not contain himself. This is what learning looks like.
“What truly matters?”…What matters is that we are all inherently learners.
Somehow the machine of learning, the industrial approach to learning begins to whittle at our organic need to thrive in wonder. I suspect the moment that we began, as a species, questioning the purpose of learning and hooking other aspirations to the purpose is the moment learning got more complicated than it needed to. The moment that aptitude was measured, skills were evaluated, retention was challenged, comparisons were leveled, people were segmented, was the moment that we stepped away from learningtowards education. This is a new idea for my thinking, but it matters.
My son is sitting beside me playing with a Rubik’s Cube. He is nothing short of enraptured by the puzzle. He turns it, and considers. He sits it down and twists and contorts himself and his perspective trying to see the inner logic of the toy. This all began because he walked in on his Mom watching a video about a Rubik’s Cube savant. He knew his sister had one. We found it. He’s been consumed with the puzzle ever since. He’s literally waiting for some insight without reservation. This morning he asked if he could watch an expert video to get some ideas. He only asked once; he got sidetracked by his own discovery.
What truly matters is we didn’t invent learning. It is not a discovery. It is the discovery. That we are a being that can ask questions, and look for answers, and, if we’re lucky, never really find the answers we seek. Instead, we discover more questions. [Italics, bold mine]
Try this on for size…
Imagine your school, your classroom if you decided to address how you might reduce the levels of stress, anxiety, and depression for your students. Explore this with Ryan’s Five Question approach and think about sharing that with us. Here you go…
There’s growing evidence that schools are contributing to rising levels of student stress, anxiety, and depression. Wait! What?…
I wonder why… we grade kids in school?
I wonder if… it would be better not to grade kids (or teachers)?
Couldn’t we at least try… to reduce the use of grades as measures of learning?
How could I help… my school, my students, my colleagues adjust to such a change?
What really matters to me? In my school? In my classroom?